• Practice
  • About 15 min
  • 5 practice questions

Lime-soda in practice: impure chemicals, daily requirement and cost

Apply the lime-soda formulae to a daily flow, correct for the purity of lime and soda, and compare the cost of treatment.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

In lesson 4 you used the lime-soda formulae with pure chemicals. Real plants use impure lime and soda, treat thousands of litres a day, and care about cost. This lesson extends the same two brackets to these practical questions. The structure of every question is the same: fill in the brackets, multiply by the factor and the volume, divide by purity, and then (if asked) multiply by price. The prices below are illustrative practice values, not market rates.

The formulae again

All hardness values as ppm of CaCO3. Lime (pure) = 74/100 × [temporary Ca + 2 × temporary Mg + permanent Mg] mg per litre. Soda (pure) = 106/100 × [permanent Ca + permanent Mg] mg per litre. Multiply by the volume in litres for milligrams, divide by 10^6 for kilograms. Divide by the purity fraction for the mass of impure chemical. Sodium and potassium salts do not appear in either bracket.

Worked example 1: daily requirement

A plant treats 20,000 L of water a day. Its hardness is: temporary Ca 60 ppm, temporary Mg 30 ppm, permanent Ca 40 ppm and permanent Mg 20 ppm. Lime per litre = 0.74 × (60 + 2 × 30 + 20) = 0.74 × 140 = 103.6 mg. Soda per litre = 1.06 × (40 + 20) = 63.6 mg. For 20,000 L: pure lime = 103.6 × 20,000 = 2,072,000 mg = 2.072 kg, and pure soda = 63.6 × 20,000 = 1,272,000 mg = 1.272 kg.

Worked example 2: purity

The lime available is 90% pure and the soda is 98% pure. Lime to be weighed = 2.072 ÷ 0.90 = 2.302 kg. Soda to be weighed = 1.272 ÷ 0.98 = 1.298 kg. The impure masses are always larger than the pure masses. A student who multiplies by the purity instead of dividing gets 1.865 kg for lime, a figure smaller than the pure requirement, which should be rejected at once.

Worked example 3: cost

Suppose lime costs ₹8 per kg and soda ₹40 per kg (illustrative). Cost of lime = 2.302 × 8 = ₹18.4. Cost of soda = 1.298 × 40 = ₹51.9. Total = ₹70.3 per day for 20,000 L, which is about ₹3.5 per 1000 L. Notice that although the plant weighs out more lime, the soda costs more, because at these illustrative prices a kilogram of soda is five times dearer. Prices change, so always use the ones the question gives.

Working backwards

A lime requirement of 74 g (pure) removes hardness equal to 100 g of CaCO3 when the hardness is temporary calcium. In 500 L this corresponds to 100,000 mg ÷ 500 L = 200 ppm of temporary calcium hardness. Similarly 106 g of pure soda removes 100 g of CaCO3 equivalent of permanent hardness, so 53 g of soda in 1000 L corresponds to 50 ppm.

Counts per unit of hardness (as CaCO3)
Type of hardnessLime factorSoda factor
Temporary calcium10
Temporary magnesium20
Permanent calcium01
Permanent magnesium11

Pure lime = 0.74 × [Ca-T + 2Mg-T + Mg-P]; pure soda = 1.06 × [Ca-P + Mg-P]. Impure mass = pure mass ÷ purity. Cost = mass in kg × price per kg.

Key takeaways

  • Fill the two brackets before multiplying by the factor and the volume.
  • Divide by the purity fraction; an impure chemical always weighs more than the pure requirement.
  • Convert mg to kg by dividing by 10^6.
  • Permanent magnesium needs both lime and soda.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Water has temporary Ca 40 ppm and temporary Mg 20 ppm and no other hardness. The pure lime needed per litre is:

    1. 29.6 mg
    2. 44.4 mg
    3. 59.2 mg
    4. 74.0 mg
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Lime = 0.74 × (40 + 2 × 20) = 0.74 × 80 = 59.2 mg per litre.

  2. 2. Water has permanent Ca 30 ppm and permanent Mg 20 ppm. The pure soda needed per litre is:

    1. 53 mg
    2. 74 mg
    3. 37 mg
    4. 106 mg
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Soda = 1.06 × (30 + 20) = 53 mg per litre.

  3. 3. A calculation gives 2.072 kg of pure lime. The lime available is 80% pure. The mass to be used is:

    1. 1.66 kg
    2. 2.59 kg
    3. 2.07 kg
    4. 3.20 kg
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Mass = 2.072 ÷ 0.80 = 2.59 kg.

  4. 4. At illustrative prices of ₹8 per kg of lime and ₹40 per kg of soda, 2.0 kg of lime and 1.0 kg of soda cost:

    1. ₹48
    2. ₹56
    3. ₹66
    4. ₹80
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Lime 2.0 × 8 = ₹16; soda 1.0 × 40 = ₹40; total ₹56.

  5. 5. 74 g of pure lime removes temporary calcium hardness equal to 100 g of CaCO3. In 500 L of water this corresponds to a hardness of:

    1. 50 ppm
    2. 100 ppm
    3. 400 ppm
    4. 200 ppm
    Show answer

    Answer: D. 100 g = 100,000 mg; 100,000 mg ÷ 500 L = 200 mg/L = 200 ppm.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery