- Practice
- About 16 min
- 5 practice questions
Mixed water-chemistry problem set: from analysis to treatment
Chain the methods of the whole course in multi-step problems: convert salts to CaCO3 equivalents, sort them, calculate lime, soda and salt, check with EDTA, and judge COD and BOD together.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
The final problems on water chemistry in exams chain several steps. A list of salts leads to hardness, which leads to chemical quantities, which may be checked by a titration or compared with pollution measures. Mistakes tend to occur in the order of the steps. This lesson works one analysis through every stage so that you see the order, and then gives a checklist. The data are illustrative practice values.
The route
- Convert every Ca and Mg salt to ppm of CaCO3 (mass × 100 ÷ molar mass).
- Label each as temporary (hydrogencarbonates) or permanent (chlorides, sulphates). Cross out sodium salts.
- Add to get temporary, permanent and total hardness.
- Choose the method and fill in its brackets (lime-soda) or its factor (zeolite).
- Scale by volume, convert to kilograms, apply purity.
Worked example 1: analysis to hardness
Water contains per litre: Ca(HCO3)2 81 mg, Mg(HCO3)2 73 mg, CaSO4 68 mg, MgCl2 47.5 mg and NaCl 100 mg. Conversions: 81 × 100 ÷ 162 = 50; 73 × 100 ÷ 146 = 50; 68 × 100 ÷ 136 = 50; 47.5 × 100 ÷ 95 = 50; NaCl does not count. Temporary = 50 (Ca) + 50 (Mg) = 100 ppm; permanent = 50 (Ca) + 50 (Mg) = 100 ppm; total = 200 ppm.
Worked example 2: lime and soda for 5000 L
Lime per litre = 0.74 × (temporary Ca 50 + 2 × temporary Mg 50 + permanent Mg 50) = 0.74 × 200 = 148 mg. Soda per litre = 1.06 × (permanent Ca 50 + permanent Mg 50) = 106 mg. For 5000 L: lime = 148 × 5000 = 740,000 mg = 0.74 kg; soda = 106 × 5000 = 530,000 mg = 0.53 kg.
Worked example 3: the zeolite alternative
For the same 5000 L, the zeolite process removes all 200 ppm of hardness: 200 × 5000 = 1,000,000 mg = 1.0 kg of CaCO3 equivalent. Regeneration salt = 1.0 × 117 ÷ 100 = 1.17 kg of NaCl. Note that zeolite replaces all 200 ppm of hardness with sodium salts, while lime-soda adds sodium salts only for the 100 ppm of permanent hardness but leaves some residual hardness; the choice depends on the intended use.
Worked example 4: an EDTA cross-check
How much 0.01 M EDTA would 50 mL of this water need? Hardness 200 ppm means 200 mg/L, which is 200 × 0.050 = 10 mg of CaCO3 in 50 mL, that is 10 ÷ 100 = 0.10 mmol. EDTA reacts 1 : 1, so volume = 0.10 mmol ÷ 0.01 mmol/mL = 10 mL. The formula gives the same: 200 × 50 ÷ (0.01 × 100 × 1000) = 10 mL. If the titre in the lab came out different from 10 mL, the analysis or the titration would need rechecking.
Worked example 5: pollution measures side by side
An effluent sample is analysed: for COD, 25 mL sample, blank 15.0 mL and sample 10.0 mL of 0.1 N FAS. COD = (15.0 − 10.0) × 0.1 × 8 × 1000 ÷ 25 = 160 mg/L. A BOD measurement gives 120 mg/L. BOD ÷ COD = 0.75, so most of the organic matter is biodegradable. BOD cannot exceed COD, so a reported BOD above 160 mg/L would indicate an error.
Hardness in other units
A water of 14 °Cl is about 14 × 14.3 = 200 ppm. If all of it were temporary calcium hardness, the lime needed would be 0.74 × 200 = 148 mg/L, the same as above. Check the unit of any hardness figure before you begin.
Checklist for multi-step questions
- Is the volume in litres? Is the hardness in ppm, °Fr or °Cl?
- Is the chemical pure? Divide by purity for the mass to weigh.
- Does the question want the pure requirement or the amount of impure chemical?
- Is the answer in mg, g or kg? Does it have a sensible size?
Sort, convert, add; fill the brackets; scale by volume; divide by purity. Check with an independent route (EDTA volume or BOD below COD) whenever the data allow.
Key takeaways
- Work in a fixed order: convert, sort, add, treat, scale, correct for purity.
- The same hardness figure feeds lime-soda, zeolite and EDTA calculations.
- BOD cannot be larger than COD; their ratio shows biodegradability.
- Check units at the start and the size of the answer at the end.
Check your understanding
-
1. For the water analysed above (temporary Ca 50, temporary Mg 50, permanent Ca 50, permanent Mg 50 ppm), the pure lime needed per litre is:
- 148 mg
- 74 mg
- 111 mg
- 200 mg
Show answer
Answer: A. Lime = 0.74 × (50 + 2 × 50 + 50) = 0.74 × 200 = 148 mg per litre.
-
2. For the same water, the pure soda needed per litre is:
- 53 mg
- 159 mg
- 106 mg
- 212 mg
Show answer
Answer: C. Soda = 1.06 × (50 + 50) = 106 mg per litre.
-
3. 5000 L of the water (200 ppm total hardness) is softened by sodium zeolite. The salt needed to regenerate the bed is:
- 1.00 kg
- 1.17 kg
- 2.34 kg
- 0.585 kg
Show answer
Answer: B. Hardness removed = 200 × 5000 = 1,000,000 mg = 1.0 kg as CaCO3; NaCl = 1.0 × 117 ÷ 100 = 1.17 kg.
-
4. The volume of 0.01 M EDTA needed by 50 mL of the same water (200 ppm) is:
- 5 mL
- 20 mL
- 2 mL
- 10 mL
Show answer
Answer: D. Hardness in 50 mL = 10 mg CaCO3 = 0.10 mmol; EDTA volume = 0.10 ÷ 0.01 = 10 mL.
-
5. An effluent has COD 160 mg/L and BOD 120 mg/L. The BOD/COD ratio is:
- 0.75
- 1.33
- 0.25
- 0.50
Show answer
Answer: A. 120 ÷ 160 = 0.75, which means that most of the organic matter is biodegradable. The ratio cannot exceed 1.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.