• Practice
  • About 15 min
  • 5 practice questions

Temporary, permanent and total hardness problems

Sort a list of dissolved salts into temporary and permanent hardness, add them correctly, and work backwards from a hardness value to the mass of salt or scale.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

Most exam questions on hardness give a list of salts with their masses and ask for temporary, permanent or total hardness, sometimes for a whole tank of water. The method is always the same: sort, convert, add. This lesson drills that method and the traps placed in the options.

Step 1: sort the salts

Hydrogencarbonates of calcium and magnesium give temporary hardness. Chlorides, sulphates and nitrates of calcium and magnesium give permanent hardness. Sodium and potassium salts, and any substance that is not a calcium or magnesium salt, are crossed out. A useful habit is to write T, P or X beside each salt before calculating anything.

Step 2: convert, then add

Convert each calcium or magnesium salt to CaCO3 equivalents with mass × 100 ÷ molar mass. Add the T values for temporary hardness and the P values for permanent hardness. Total hardness is temporary plus permanent. Never add the raw masses of the salts: different salts carry different amounts of hardness per milligram.

Worked example 1: a full analysis

A water sample contains, per litre: Ca(HCO3)2 81 mg, Mg(HCO3)2 73 mg, CaSO4 136 mg, MgCl2 95 mg and NaCl 50 mg. Sort: the two hydrogencarbonates are T, CaSO4 and MgCl2 are P, NaCl is X. Convert: 81 × 100/162 = 50; 73 × 100/146 = 50; 136 × 100/136 = 100; 95 × 100/95 = 100. Temporary hardness = 50 + 50 = 100 ppm. Permanent hardness = 100 + 100 = 200 ppm. Total = 300 ppm. An option of 350 ppm would come from wrongly adding the sodium chloride.

Worked example 1 laid out
Saltmg/LTypeAs CaCO3 (ppm)
Ca(HCO3)281T50
Mg(HCO3)273T50
CaSO4136P100
MgCl295P100
NaCl50X0

Worked example 2: hardness in a tank

A tank holds 500 L of water of total hardness 200 ppm. How much hardness, as CaCO3, does it contain? 200 mg per litre × 500 L = 100,000 mg = 100 g of CaCO3 equivalent. For tank questions, multiply ppm by litres to get milligrams, then divide by 1000 for grams.

Worked example 3: working backwards

A water sample has 150 ppm of permanent hardness, all caused by MgSO4. What mass of MgSO4 is dissolved per litre? Reverse the conversion: mass = hardness × molar mass ÷ 100 = 150 × 120 ÷ 100 = 180 mg per litre.

Worked example 4: scale from boiling

1500 L of water has 120 ppm of temporary hardness, all from Ca(HCO3)2. On complete boiling, what mass of CaCO3 scale forms? The hardness is already expressed as CaCO3, and each Ca(HCO3)2 gives one CaCO3, so the scale equals the hardness: 120 mg/L × 1500 L = 180,000 mg = 180 g. There is no need to go through Ca(HCO3)2 at all.

Why the split matters

The distinction is not just bookkeeping. Temporary hardness can be removed cheaply by boiling or with lime, whereas permanent hardness needs soda or an exchanger, so the split decides the cost of softening. It also decides the chemical quantities in the lime-soda calculation of lesson 4, where temporary and permanent hardness go into different brackets.

Traps to watch

  • Boiling turns Mg(HCO3)2 into Mg(OH)2, but its hardness is still counted as temporary.
  • NaHCO3 is a hydrogencarbonate but not a hardness salt; it adds alkalinity, not hardness.
  • Total hardness is the sum of CaCO3 equivalents, never the sum of salt masses.
  • Read whether the question asks for temporary, permanent or total; the options usually include all three.

Sort (T, P or X), convert each to CaCO3 with × 100 ÷ M, then add. Total = temporary + permanent. For a tank, ppm × litres = mg.

— Rule to remember

Key takeaways

A three-step routine solves almost every hardness question: sort, convert, add. Work backwards with mass = hardness × M ÷ 100. When the hardness is already given as CaCO3, the mass of carbonate scale from boiling is the same number, scaled by the volume. Keep sodium salts and sodium hydrogencarbonate out of the sum.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Water contains, per litre, 32.4 mg Ca(HCO3)2 and 24 mg MgSO4. What is its temporary hardness?

    1. 20 ppm
    2. 40 ppm
    3. 32.4 ppm
    4. 44 ppm
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Only Ca(HCO3)2 is temporary: 32.4 × 100/162 = 20 ppm.

  2. 2. For the same water (32.4 mg/L Ca(HCO3)2 and 24 mg/L MgSO4), what is the total hardness?

    1. 44 ppm
    2. 56.4 ppm
    3. 40 ppm
    4. 20 ppm
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Temporary 20 ppm; permanent 24 × 100/120 = 20 ppm. Total = 40 ppm. Adding raw masses (56.4) is the trap.

  3. 3. How much hardness, as CaCO3, is contained in 2000 L of water of hardness 200 ppm?

    1. 40 g
    2. 400 g
    3. 4 kg
    4. 200 g
    Show answer

    Answer: B. 200 mg/L × 2000 L = 400,000 mg = 400 g.

  4. 4. Water has 100 ppm permanent hardness, all from CaCl2. What mass of CaCl2 is present per litre?

    1. 100 mg
    2. 90 mg
    3. 55.5 mg
    4. 111 mg
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Mass = 100 × 111 ÷ 100 = 111 mg per litre.

  5. 5. Which pair of salts both cause permanent hardness?

    1. Ca(HCO3)2 and MgCl2
    2. MgCl2 and CaSO4
    3. NaCl and CaSO4
    4. Mg(HCO3)2 and NaHCO3
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Chlorides and sulphates of calcium and magnesium cause permanent hardness. Hydrogencarbonates are temporary; sodium salts cause none.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery